Today the Charlotte Observer
announced the winner of the Charlotte Chamber of Commerce skyline photo competition.
I like the photo, but I wanted to point out a few thoughts in the Observer's coverage.
1) The most obvious error is the date when the article says the photo was taken, " the panoramic photo was taken in July." The progress of the Duke Energy Center in this photo is between the beginning of Feb. and the end of March. Definitely not summer.
2) The headline, by Observer Business and Development writer Kerry Hall Singe, reads "Winning Skyline Image Reflects Downturn" - I'm not sure how you can get that from the image. Let's examine:
3) "As uptown development has slowed, this year's photo features fewer cranes than in prior years." Maybe. After all, the Ritz-Carlton, Catalyst, 440 South Church, Aloft Hotel, and NASCAR tower had all topped out, and their cranes had come down. Still, this photo does not show two cranes for the Vue, two cranes for 1 Bank of America, and a crane for the new UNC-Charlotte uptown building. If anything, it is a "downturn to normal."
4) "Also visible toward the right, however, is The Park condo tower, which has been stalled since last year." True, but the writer fails to mention The Park has been bought by a developer with a scheduled construction restart this coming Feb. Why bother going into detail about how much Mark Martin spent on a condo at Royal Court but leave off this fact?
5) Just a personal preference, but it is obvious the green coloration has been Photoshoped onto the construction dirt at the bottom of the photo. This is just personal opinion, but I prefer a bit more honesty in my photos. You know
who else likes to Photoshop their photos, don't you?
6) The "hi-resolution" version isn't by any definition. Actually, it is a screen cap - with the mouse pointer visible.
7) I miss Doug Smith.
8) If you want development news, just read the Charlotte forum at
urbanplanet.org9) Why, no, I'm not bitter about not winning the contest. I just find the Observer's coverage to be pretty funny. "But the mouse pointer is still visible. Ah, who will notice."